Houses in historic districts are classified as either "contributing" or "non-contributing".
"Contributing" houses date from the historic period of the district and contribute to the historic significance and character of the district.
A house that was built later, or significantly altered, may be "non-contributing".
Why Should Laurelhurst Be A Historic District?
We are a uniquely cohesive, preserved neighborhood of fine Portland houses from the 1910s through 1930s.
Laurelhurst began in 1909 as one of the earliest planned neighborhoods in the Western US.
Formerly Hazelfern Farm, the neighborhood was platted as four quadrants around a central roundabout (Coe Circle), with a concentric street pattern, a distinct boundary marked with prominent arches at major street entrances.
The neighborhood includes Laurelhurst Park, also designed by John Olmsted, and street tree plantings which, over a hundred years, are a mature urban forest in the heart of Portland.
No multi-family housing or commercial development has ever been permitted in the neighborhood.
Laurelhurst has come through the past century as a remarkably intact neighborhood of single family houses that looks very much as it did between the two world wars, and includes more houses of traditional Portland architecture, built in the 1910s through 1930s and preserved in their original condition, than almost any other neighborhood in the city.
This intact fabric of Portland history qualifies Laurelhurst for National Register Historic District status.
How Does Historic District Designation Protect A Neighborhood?
A contributing house may not be demolished without Demolition Review.
A demolition request is reviewed by the city Landmarks Commission and may be approved by the City Council. The design of the replacement structure must be approved before demolition.
Non-contributing houses may be demolished without review, but the replacement house will be subject to Historic Resource Review (see below).
Most remodeling projects are not affected by Historic District status (are “exempt”).
Repair, maintenance, and painting: exempt. There is no restriction on paint color.
Storm/screen doors and storm/screen windows: exempt.
Fences, gates, street and retaining walls, patios, decks, landscaping: all exempt.
Interior alterations: exempt. Historic Districts do not affect interior remodeling at all.
Exterior alterations to a non-contributing house: exempt, if non-street-facing and not large (150 sq ft of exterior).
Construction of small detached structures away from lot lines: exempt. These are structures up to 200 sq ft, 40 feet from the front lot line and, for corner lots, 25 feet from the side street lot line.
Basement windows and light wells: exempt, for typical windows/wells.
Solar panels, skylights, rooftop vents and equipment: exempt, if they meet size/location standards intended to reduce visibility from the street, e.g. solar panels on the rear of a roof.
These projects do not require any special review or fee, beyond standard building permits.
New houses, or exterior alterations to existing houses, go through a Historic Resource Review.
Most projects receive the simplest Type I review by city Bureau of Development Services staff, which takes 35 days.
Large projects, up to $437,750 of exterior work, receive Type II review, which takes 42 days.
Very large projects exceeding $437,750 of exterior work (typically a new house, some very large additions) receive a detailed Type III review by the Historic Landmarks Commission. The review fee is 3.2% of project cost, up to $5,000.
Design Review considers whether the construction will preserve the house’s historic character, features, and architectural design, and be consistent with the neighborhood’s historic character and scale.
Historic District designation will limit impact from infill (density) rezoning.
The city’s proposed “residential infill” zoning in Laurelhurst and other Portland neighborhoods will allow two or more accessory dwelling units (ADUs) with a single-family house; all houses could be duplexes; corner lots could be triplexes; double lots could be small apartment complexes. This will encourage demolition of existing houses to build duplexes, triplexes, and apartments.
If Laurelhurst becomes a Historic District:
ADUs would still be permitted, if visually consistent with the main house.
It will be very difficult to demolish contributing houses. They could be converted to duplexes/triplexes, but the exterior appearance must be consistent with the neighborhood’s historic character and architecture.
Non-contributing houses could be demolished, but the replacement structure must be consistent with the neighborhood’s historic character and architecture.
Historic District designation increases or stabilizes property values.
By preserving historic character, Historic Districts support property values. Irvington has been a Historic District since 2010, Ladd’s Addition since 1988, values in those neighborhoods have been protected.
Studies in other cities consistently show the positive impact of Historic Designation.
Historic Districts do not increase property tax rates. No special fees are levied on houses in Historic Districts. In some cases, contributing houses can get property tax abatement via Oregon Special Assessment Program. If the property is income-producing, the Federal Rehabilitation Tax Credit may be available.